If you have one song that asks a question or makes a statement, come up with a different song that answers/responds to that question
For example: Shakira's "Whenever, Whenever" would be the response to Jesus Jones' "Right Here, Right Now"
Entries starting with P are split into multiple pages: 1 2 3 4
Song & Band Name | Response Song & Band Name | Comments & Submittor Name | ||
| "P.S. I Love You," The Beatles | "I Love You Too," Ziggy Marley | Rychendroll | ||
| "P.S. I Love You," Beatles | "There I've Said It Again," Bobby Vinton | Kathy | ||
| "P.S. I Love You," Beatles | "Let Your Love Flow," Bellamy Brothers | Kathy | ||
| "Pac-Man Fever," Buckner & Garcia | "I'm Old Fashioned," Ella Fitzgerald | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Pac-Man Fever," Buckner & Garcia | "Pinball Wizard," The Who | Kathy | ||
| "Pack Up," National Skyline | "I Don't Want To Leave You," Kieran Goss | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Pack Up," National Skyline | "I Wish You Wouldn't Say That," Talking Heads | But I don't wanna pack up! - Dylan B. | ||
| "Pack Up Your Troubles In Your Old Kit Bag," Spike Jones | "Smile Smile Smile," Dan Zanes | Kathy | ||
| "Painkiller," Judas Priest | "It Don't Hurt No More," Nappy Brown | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Palisades Park," Freddy Cannon | "Fun Fun Fun," The Beach Boys | Rychendroll | ||
| "Panic," The Smiths | "Don't Panic," Coldplay | Josh | ||
| "Papa Don't Preach," Madonna | "Bad Romance," Lady Gaga | Dad's feelings in the PDP video! - Robert D. Arndt Jr. | ||
| "Papa Don't Preach," Madonna | "Speechless," Lady Gaga | Robert D. Arndt Jr. | ||
| "Papa's Got A Brand New Bag," James Brown | "Brown Paper Bag," DJ Khaled | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Papa's Got A Brand New Bag," James Brown | "I Got A Bag Of My Own," James Brown | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Papa's Got A Brand New Bag," James Brown | "Plastic Or Paper?," The Bobs | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Papa's Got A Brand New Bag," James Brown | "Little Green Bag," George Baker Selection | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow," The Rivingtons | "I Just Don't Understand," Ann-Margret | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Paper Cup," The 5th Dimension | "Dixie," Traditional | Dixie is a brand name of paper cups.. - Ugly Kid Joe Cocker | ||
| "Paper Cup," The Fifth Dimension | "Torn," Natalie Imbruglia | Uni Roy Al | ||
| "Paper Cup," The 5th Dimension | "Paper In Fire," John Mellencamp | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Paper Cup," The 5th Dimension | "Paper In Fire," John Mellencamp | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Paper Cup," The 5th Dimension | "Trash," Korn | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Paper Cup," The 5th Dimension | "Pour Me A Drink," Nanci Griffith | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Paper In Fire," John Mellencamp | "We Didn't Start The Fire," Billy Joel | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Paper Roses," Marie Osmond | "Pretty Flowers," Steve Martin | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Paper Roses," Marie Osmond | "Roses Are Red," Bobby Vinton | Kathy | ||
| "Paper Roses," Marie Osmond | "Artificial Flowers," Bobby Darin | Candy Welty | ||
| "Paper Shoes," Incubus | "Paper Cuts," Nirvana | Or blisters, one of the two. - Garrison | ||
| "Paperback Writer," The Beatles | "Everyday I Write The Book," Elvis Costello & The Attractions | Candy Welty | ||
| "Paperback Writer," The Beatles | "With Pen In Hand," Vikki Carr | Kathy | ||
| "Paperback Writer," The Beatles | "I Wrote The Book," Beth Ditto | Candy Welty | ||
| "Pardon Me," Incubus | "Go To Hell," Megadeth | But I barely bumped you! - Josh | ||
| "Part Of Me," Katy Perry | "Legs," ZZ Top | Brian Kelly | ||
| "Part Of Me," Katy Perry | "Hands," Jewel | Brian Kelly | ||
| "Part Of Me," Katy Perry | "Eye," The Smashing Pumpkins | Brian Kelly | ||
| "Part Of Me," Katy Perry | "Mouth," Merril Bainbridge | Cassandra | ||
| "Part Of Me," Katy Perry | "My Brave Face," Paul McCartney | Brian Kelly | ||
| "Part Of Me, Part Of You," Glenn Frey | "A Little Bit Me, A Little Bit You," The Monkees | Kathy | ||
| "Party All The Time," Eddie Murphy | "All She Wants To Do Is Dance," Don Henley | Kathy | ||
| "Party All The Time," Eddie Murphy | "No Work, All Play," Hilary Duff | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Party All The Time," Eddie Murphy | "Dance Forever," Allstar Weekend | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Party In My Head," Sophie Ellis-Bextor | "Get The Party Started," Pink | Wendy Torrance | ||
| "Party On The Moon," Vanessa Hudgens | "Everyone's Gone To The Moon," Jonathan King | Shannon Ingrid Travis | ||
| "Party On The Moon," Vanessa Hudgens | "Get The Party Started," Pink | Wendy Torrance | ||
| "Passionate Kisses," Mary Chapin Carpenter | "Kiss Me Like That," Kiley Dean | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Passionate Kisses," Mary Chapin Carpenter | "Kiss On My List," Hall & Oates | Kathy | ||
| "A Past And Future Secret," Blind Guardian | "I Told A Stranger," Rita Raines | Wendy Torrance | ||
| "Patches," Clarence Carter | "Patch It Up," Elvis Presley | Kathy | ||
| "The Patient," Tool | "The Nurse Who Loved Me," A Perfect Circle | Josh | ||
| "Patiently Waiting," 50 Cent featuring Eminem | "Waiting For A Girl Like You," Foreigner | Candy Welty | ||
| "Pay Me," Usher | "Pay You Back With Interest," The Hollies | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Pay Me," Usher | "Ain't Got No Money," Bob Seger | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Pay Me," Usher | "A Dollar's Worth Of Pennies," Tommy Roe | Melanie Black | ||
| "Pay To The Piper," Chairmen Of The Board | "The Pied Piper," Crispian St. Peters | Kathy | ||
| "Paying The Cost To Be The Boss," B.B. King | "Big Shot," Billy Joel | Kathy | ||
| "Peace Of Mind," Boston | "Peaceful Easy Feeling," The Eagles | Kathy | ||
| "Peace Song," Indigo Girls | "Give Peace A Chance," John Lennon | Kathy | ||
| "Peanut Butter," The Marathons | "Spread It On Thick," The Gentrys | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Peanut Butter," The Marathons | "Don't Spread It Around," Barbara Lynn | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Peanut Butter," The Marathons | "Peanut Butter & Jelly," Christina Milian | Kathy | ||
| "The Peanut Vendor," Jack Purvis | "Salt Peanuts," Terry Gibbs | Kathy | ||
| "Pearl Necklace," ZZ Top | "You Wear It Well," Rod Stewart | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "A Penny For Your Thoughts," Tavares | "Three Coins In The Fountain," The Four Aces | Kathy | ||
| "Penny Loafers And Bobby Socks," Joe Bennett & The Sparkletones | "Back To The 50's," Hoodie Allen | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Penny Lover," Lionel Richie | "For The Love Of Money," The O'Jays | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "People Are Strange," The Doors | "People Sure Act Funny," Arthur Conley | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "People Gotta Move," Gino Vannelli | "(Shake, Shake, Shake) Shake Your Booty)," KC & The Sunshine Band | Kathy | ||
| "The People In Me," The Music Machine | "Abraham, Martin And John," Dion | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "The People In Me," The Music Machine | "Roger, Ed And Gus," Tommy Dee | Candy Welty | ||
| "The People In Me," The Music Machine | "Jackie, Bobby, Sonny, Billy," Linda Carr | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "People Will Say We're In Love," Gordon MacRae & Shirley Jones | "Almost Like Being In Love," Nat King Cole | Kathy | ||
| "Perfect Love," Trisha Yearwood | "Nothing Is Perfect," Neil Young | Candy Welty | ||
| "Philly Dog," Herbie Mann | "Rover," Jethro Tull | Candy Welty | ||
| "Phony Calls," Weird Al Yankovic | "I Can't Stand It," Eric Clapton | Mimi Molly Hatchet | ||
| "Photograph," Ringo Starr | "Black & White," Three Dog Night | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Photograph," Ringo Starr | "Pictures Of Matchstick Men," Status Quo | Kathy | ||
| "Photograph," Ringo Starr | "Instant Photo," Louise Goffin | Kathy | ||
| "Photograph," Ringo Starr | "Always Something There To Remind Me," Naked Eyes | Candy Welty | ||
| "Photograph," Ringo Starr | "Capture The Moment," Jay & The Americans | Candy Welty | ||
| "Photographs And Memories," Jim Croce | "Always Something There To Remind Me," Naked Eyes | Candy Welty | ||
| "Physical," Olivia Newton-John | "Bend Me, Shape Me," American Breed | Kathy | ||
| "Physical," Olivia Newton-John | "More Than Physical," Bananarama | Candy Welty | ||
| "Physical," Olivia Newton-John | "Baby Workout," Jackie Wilson | Kathy | ||
| "Piano Man," Billy Joel | "Piano In The Dark," Brenda Russell | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Piano Man," Billy Joel | "Play Something Country," Brooks & Dunn | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Piano Man," Billy Joel | "Play It All Night Long," Warren Zevon | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Piano Man," Billy Joel | "Old Upright Piano," Nitty Gritty Dirt Band | Kathy | ||
| "Pick Me Up On Your Way Down," Patsy Cline | "Pick Yourself Up," Diana Krall | Wendy Torrance | ||
| "Pick Up The Phone," Ciara | "Call Me When You're Sober," Evanescence | Bobolina | ||
| "Pick Up The Phone," Ciara | "Nobody's Home," Avril Lavigne | stop calling! - Bobolina | ||
| "Pick Up The Pieces," Average White Band | "Picking Up The Pieces," Paloma Faith | Kathy | ||
| "Pick Up The Pieces," Average White Band | "One Piece At A Time," Johnny Cash | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Pick Up The Pieces," Average White Band | "Every Single One," Geoff Moore | Candy Welty | ||
| "Pick Yourself Up," Diana Krall | "Pick Up The Pieces," Average White Band | Kathy | ||
| "Pickle Up A Doodle," Teresa Brewer | "I Just Don't Understand," Ann-Margret | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Picnic," The McGuire Sisters | "Those Lazy Hazy Crazy Days Of Summer," Nat King Cole | Kathy | ||
| "Picture Of You," My Morning Jacket | "Nail It To The Wall," Stacy Lattisaw | Yvette Bristle | ||
| "Pieces Of Me," Ashlee Simpson | "A Little Bit Me, A Little Bit You," The Monkees | Wendy Torrance | ||
| "Pieces Of Me," Ashlee Simpson | "No Such Thing," John Mayer | Not in the literal sense, anyways - Beth |
Entries starting with P are split into multiple pages: 1 2 3 4
New entries in this section are currently reviewed by nally. Previous editors (if any) are listed on the editors page.
Got something that should be added to this page? Check out the submission form.